All crumb, with little crust. I know this might not be the idea you have of a classic French bread, but it is the best way to describe this Pain de mie, which is a delicious French household staple in France.
Now the truth is, while growing up in France, I was not particularly fond of this style of bread. Pain de Mie is sold in every French supermarket and grocery store, sliced and packaged. And seeing these industrial-like, pre-packaged and sliced soft white breads is a vision that never really appealed to me (I much preferred a trip to my neighborhood bakery for a freshly baked, crusty baguette).
But this recipe (which I started to make just a few weeks ago) definitly reconciled my relationship with Pain de Mie. In fact, it made me fall in love with it.
“Mie” means crumb in French. And indeed, this “Bread of the Crumb” title calls attention to the almost-absent crust on this bread, and its particularly tight crumb – which contrasts with the crunchy crusts and airy crumbs you find in most French breads, such as baguettes, boules and rustic loaves.
As I mentioned, Pain de Mie is sold in every French supermarket and grocery store, sliced and packaged. If you sneak into the cupboards of any given French kicthen (in any region of France), chances are you will find a package or two of this Pain de Mie. It is beloved for its mild taste and soft and creamy texture, which makes it very versatile and perfect for breakfast toasts, sandwiches, fancy french toasts, canapes or even soup croutons. Its original square shape also makes it ideal for preparing a cheesy croque-monsieur or a croque-madame (which is the same as a croque-monsieur, but with an egg on top!).
It is also particularly enjoyed by French housewives, because it keeps fresher longer than French-bakery breads, owing to the fat in it (from the oil and milk), which other French breads usually lack. It keeps very well inside its package, for up to a week, and freezes well too.
This recipe is so simple yet great. It gives you the same softness and creaminess as any store-bought French Pain de Mie, but with a much fresher taste of course. We’ve been making a loaf of pain de mie every weekend, lately. We prepare the dough on Friday night, let it sit overnight and bake it on Saturday morning. My husband uses it to make sandwiches and to accompany our Sunday stews. And I love it for making French Toast.
Needless to say the loaf is usually all gone by Sunday night (and if any is left, we simply freeze it!).
Cooking notes:
- For optimum proportions, this recipe requires a scale.
- Pain de Mie is traditionally baked in a lidded Pullman bread pan. The lid constrains the expansion of the the dough and ensures a tighter crumb and perfect square shape. Because I do not have a Pullman pan, I have been making my pain de mie in a regular loaf pan (with no lid). And I am happy to say, although the top has some room to rise and crack, this recipe still produces a very tight and creamy crumb, with a paper-thin soft crust.
- This recipe is very easy to make, and you do not require a stand mixer. Although you can use one if you wish.
- The dough should be prepared the day before, and be allowed to sit overnight in a fridge. This creates a slow rise, with a lot more flavour!
If you try this Classic Pain de mie, let me know! Leave a comment or share a photo using #pardonyourfrench on Instagram.
Bon Appétit!
46 comments
Loving your recipes. It all started to make sense when I bought a scale, my success rate improved. 🙂
Thanks! Yes, all the recipes in France are actually in grams, and people use a scale. I convert most of the French recipes here to cups (because I know this is what people rely on in the US/Canada). But for some recipes, like breads, using a scale and grams is simply the only way to go 🙂
I actualy brought a couple of these pain de mie when I was in Bordeaux last year, it was so good! Like you I prefer to go my local bakery and buy baguettes, but this recipe intrigues me and I want to make it! thank you so much for this awesome recipe 🙂
Well yes, it’s hard to beat bakery-fresh breads when you’re in France. But whenever I feel like something softer and creamier, and want to make toasts or a sandwich, this recipe is my go-to!
i recently ordered a pullman pan and pan de mie was the first recipe i wanted to try in it. i’m even more excited now, can’t wait!
Nice! I need to get myself a pullman pan as well. Let me know when you try the recipe!
My Pullman Pan was delivered today. I am going to start the process tomorrow.
That’s exciting! Let me know how it turns out. I still have to buy myself a pullman pan, I have been using a classic loaf pan so far (which works great too!).
Hi Audrey , I want to try this recipe, can you convert your measurements to the American standards , 1/2 cup of milk, 30g of honey. This way I don’t have to look at a chart. I would appreciate it. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!
Hi! For sure, I have added the American measurement equivalents to the recipe – I hope you enjoy it!
So happy to have your ‘Pain de Mie’ recipe–it sounds so easy!
It’s easy and delicious, I hope you enjoy it!
Hi Audrey, Can you please tell me how long “overnight in fridge” is? I’m guessing about 9 hours but I don’t want to guess!
Thank you.
Hi Lionel. Overnight is about 12 hours, but as early as 10 hours is fine. I often make it in the evening (6-8pm) and bake it for breakfast (6am-8am). I hope this helps!
Hi Audrey, I made your Pain de Mie today and it was quite a success at our house. Thank you very much for the formula. Merry Christmas,
Happy to hear it! Thank you for your feedback Lionel!
Hi, How big is your pan? I have a 13-inch pain de mie pan, but it seems yours is smaller. I want to adjust the measure me accordingly.
Hi, that’s a great question! My pan here is 8-1/2 x 4-1/2; but you could use a slightly larger one that is 9 x 5 as well. Bigger than that, ingredient measurements will need to be adjusted 🙂
I have made this recipe now about 6 times, and it always turns out great! I have found measuring at least the flour in grams very helpful. It’s my sister’s favorite bread. Though I have a pullman pan, I cook this without the lid because I like the way it looks—just like the picture! The taste and crumb is exceptional! I’m cooking in Pueblo Colorafo USA and appreciate both grams and oz measurements in the recipe..thank you!
Amazing! Thank you for your great review Shelley.
Thanks for this recipe! Perfect quarantine recipe. Two questions:
– Should we proof the dought before the fridge?
– Can we substitute oil with butter?
Thanks!
Hi Emiliano! No you don’t need to proof the dough; it will proof and ferment slowly in the fridge. And I would recommend sticking to oil. Happy Baking!
Thank you! One more question, what would you recommend to proof this dough, and others, when it is cold outside?
Hi Emiliano! The pain de mie looked fantastic! This dough here doesn’t need to proof, other than in the fridge. For other doughs/breads, the ideal room-temperature proof is considered around 75°F. During Winter or when it’s cold outside, I like to proof doughs in my oven (off): it is usually slightly warmer in there and draft-free. I hope this helps!
Hey Audrey, the bread didnt come out glossy and fluffy as yours.. wonder why.. thinking may be I didnt knead it until it was completely smooth.. I substitute 7g of instant yeast for 9g of active… your thoughts?
Hi Marina. I always make this pain de mie with instant yeast – but the equivalent of active dry yeast you used sounds about right (you usually have to multiply the amount of yeast by 1.25 – so 7g instant yeast = 8.75 active dry). I am thinking of 2 reasons why the bread didn’t get fluffy – 1. are you sure your yeast is still active? Yeast is very perishable (I store mine in the freezer) or 2. Maybe you didn’t knead the dough until it was completely smooth. When you took the dough out of the fridge in the morning, was it doubled in size? I hope this helps!
I mixed the dough last night and was disappointed this morning when the dough was the same size. I cooked it anyway, resigned to the fact it would be a failure. But it tastes delicious!
Hi Dominique! It sounds like the yeast you used may be dead, hence why the dough didn’t rise? Or, the milk was too hot when you added it to the other ingredients, which may have killed the yeast. The milk should be a little warm, but not hot. I hope these suggestions help!
[…] chicken noodle soup is delicious, and especially nice with a fresh loaf of bread like the Classic Pain de Mie from Pardon Your French, or a grilled cheese sandwich. […]
Audrey, I make my own bread regularly and haven’t had any trouble. I will try this recipe again and see how it goes. But the first batch still tasted delicious and disappeared quickly!
Looks delicious. Can’t wait to try this in my new Pullman pan!
Thank you!
Two questions: I have a new 13x4x4 covered Pullman – can you help with the newer weights of ingredients? Also, can you use sourdough starter instead of yeast in this recipe? I can’t wait to try it, but my pan is alot bigger than what you have described and I’m not that good yet!
Hi Joy, thank you for your comment! I have made this pain de mie recipe so many times and always sticks to these proportions. I never tried using a larger pan, so I am afraid I can’t give you tips for changing proportions. I don’t like to give recommendations, if I haven’t tried it myself first 🙂 Also, I wouldn’t recommend using a sourdough starter for this specific recipe…. I found this article from The Perfect Loaf, a blog I really like. It that could be useful for you, it has a sourdough pain de mie recipe, and a table for alternate pan sizes: https://www.theperfectloaf.com/pain-de-mie/ I hope this helps!
This was delicious. I found my recipe for everyday bread!!!
Amazing, thanks!
First, I am so happy when I see measurements in grams! For me, a math challenged Americans, it just makes more sense. Secondly, Ive been searching for the right pan de mei recipe for my Pullman….my only question is, butter instead of oil? Or would that change the structure.
Hi Cynthia! Because this is only 2 tbsp of vegetable oil, you can use melted butter as a 1:1 direct substitute. Make sure the butter is melted, then let it cool down and when it’s barely warm to the touch, it’s ready to use. Happy baking!
Im about to put it in the oven. How long should I bake it. Using a Pullman
Hi Cynthia! I would suggest baking it for the exact same time, without the lid so the crumb doesn’t get too compact. Enjoy!
Your recipe sounds wonderful! Can’t wait to try it. I have a pullman pan, but the one time I tried leaving the top on, the dough leaked out and made a little mess. Maybe the dough was too wet, or maybe I made too big a batch. Does this recipe do well in a lidded pan?
Hi Jim! This recipe works great with a pullman pan, but I don’t recommend using the lid, so the crumb doesn’t get too compact (or leak out!). Enjoy!
Can this bread be made with a mix of whole wheat and white flour, or completely with whole wheat, rye etc?
Hi Asha, I would stick to all-purpose flour as this is how this recipe was developed. I did not try it with other flours so can’t guarantee the success. I hope this helps!
Thank you for your timely response!
You’re welcome!