The Garbure is a rustic soup from the Gascony region consisting of smoked ham hock, beans, cabbage and seasonal vegetables slowly stewed. It’s rich, full of smokey flavor and intentionally thick: it’s said a Garbure is ready when the ladle can stand upright in the pot. This robust soup is a great classic of French mountain cooking and best enjoyed on a blistery Winter day.
Rural origins
Like many French dishes, the Garbure was once peasant food, only cooked and enjoyed in rural areas of the South West of France. Its recipe varied from one farm to the other, following the seasons, the produces found in the gardens and meat available in the salting tubs. Eventually, the making of Garbure soup became more popular and adopted by all home cooks, not only farmers. Its recipe remains quite adaptable but always includes: cabbage, beans, potatoes, seasonal vegetables if available, and smoked or confied meat.
The making of a Garbure is best suited for weekends, when you can devote a few hours to being home. It requires time but not necessarily a lot of efforts. The recipe starts the day before with soaking the white beans overnight in a bowl of water. The day of, the cooking of the soup takes up to 4 hours, but this only includes about 30 minutes of active time. For the rest, you can simply keep an eye on the simmering pot, while going on with your other leisurely activities.
The Broth
A great Garbure starts with building a good broth. No store-bought stock in this case! The broth is made from scratch by simmering a clove-poked onion, herbs and a whole smoked ham hock for one hour. As the hock cooks, its collagen and fat melt into the broth, imparting a rich and smokey flavor unique to this meat cut.
The White beans
World-famous Tarbais Beans (“Haricots Tarbais”) are traditionally used in the preparation of a Garbure. These white beans grown in the South West region of France are beloved for their paper-thin skin, melty flesh and great resistance to cooking. They are very popular in the South of France and the base of many local recipes, including the Cassoulet.
Since Tarbais beans are harder to find in North America, you can use any good-quality white beans. Dried beans, and not canned, are the way to go for this recipe. We want the beans to soak up all the flavor from the broth while they cook yet still hold their shape – while canned beans will likely end up mushy.
The Cabbage
Like most mountain cooking, this Garbure was born from a need to adapt to the region’s climate and altitude. In the Pyreenees mountains, locals would make due with what can only grow at high altitude; in this case, potatoes and sturdy cabbages. Savoy Cabbage is at peak in the Winter, and is especially great used in soups as it doesn’t turn into mush but retain a firm texture when cooked.
Landes-Style Garbure, with duck confit.
This recipe which only includes ham is often associated with the Béarn region. This version is the oldest one, anchored in the tradition of simple, affordable peasant food. But if you travel today to the Landes, often referred to as France’s duck country, chances are you will be served a fancier version of the Garbure, including both ham and duck confit.
You can purchase duck confit in most grocery stores, usually sold vacuum-packed or in sealed jars. And if you wish to make your own duck confit, know that it is probably easier than what you think! You can find an authentic homemade duck confit recipe in my cookbook “Rustic French Cooking Made Easy“, or opt for this short-cut duck confit recipe video.
If you wish to include duck confit in this recipe, four pieces will be enough. Simply sear the duck pieces in a pan to crisp up the skin and serve each bowl of Garbure topped up with a piece of confit. Because the duck provides additional meat, you can use a smaller piece of ham hock (about 1.5 to 2lbs) to keep a good meat-vegetable ratio.
Cooking notes:
- Whole Smoked Ham Hocks can be purchased in most grocery stores, often vacuum-packed, or butcher shops.
- Because Smoked Ham Hock has an assertive salty flavor, be careful not to over-salt the broth.
- Take the time to blanch the cabbage before adding it to the soup. Blanching the cabbage will clean and soften the leaves, while keeping the flavor and nutritional value. It will also make the cabbage easier to digest.
- I love to use Russet Potatoes, also known as Idaho potatoes in North America, for making a Garbure. Once cooked, they have a fluffy flesh that enhances the “creamy”, thick texture of the soup.
- This is a great dish for feeding a large table (+8 people), or to keep in the fridge for leftovers for the next 2 or 3 days. In fact, some say a Garbure is even better reheated the next day!
I hope you’ll love this Smoked Ham Hock Bean Cabbage Soup (Garbure) recipe as much as I do! If you have any questions, please feel free to leave a comment.
You may also like:
- Classic French Beef Bourguignon
- Braised Rabbit with Prunes (Lapin aux Pruneaux)
- Classic French Lentil Soup
- Braised Chicken Thighs with Garlic and Onion
- Coq au Vin Blanc
47 comments
A must make recipe. Thank You.
Thank you, enjoy!
Excellent recipe, I will make it today !
Thank you, enjoy!
I love the spoon trick 🙂
Yes, it’s quite unique!
Amazing
Thank you!
This soup is absolutely delicious. I’m having great fun with your recipes, and my hubby loved this soup.
Thank you so much for your feedback, very happy you enjoy this soup!
Garbure sounds interesting, going to try very soon. Just purchased the ingredients today. One question: what do you do with the clove poked onion afterwards? Shed the cloves and cut the onion up to add to the soup or discard the onion & cloves as just a flavoring for the broth? Thank You.
Hi Kathy! Good question – I prefer keeping the onion (no waste). Simply discard of the cloves, slice the onion, and add it back to the soup. Enjoy!
Delicious! I’m having it with garlic bread.
Amazing, thank you!
My husband spent hours making this -and I spent hours cleaning up after him! It was completely tasteless. Far too much liquid in this recipe.
Hello, Susan. I am very sorry to hear this dish wasn’t enjoyed. I am also a little surprised you found it tasteless. Between there being smoked ham hock, 8-10 cloves (clove spice), bay leaf and thyme, the soup is usually full of flavour.
I felt the exact same way. Followed recipe to the T and it is tasteless. AND way, way, way too much liquid. I am trying to fin other spices to add to create some flavor, not complaining just sharing my experience. Maybe it is the ham hock we used (but bought from a really good butcher and had been smoked). I would suggest 12-14 C water not 18…. way too much.
It’s because you added too much water from the get-go rather than barely covering the ham at the beginning. Naturally the vegs. will release water and if you add too much you’ll end up nearly doubling the amount of the water required for the soup. Hope this helps! Thanks to the author. 🙂
Absolutely delicious. I followed the recipe exactly but was concerned about the water issue that some have had. On re-reading the recipe it says : “Add about 4.5 litres (18cups) of water OR enough to cover the ham hock”. So I covered the ham hock and it came out perfectly. I even did the spoon test and it stood up! The flavors were sooo good. Hubby was shocked there was no store bought stock in it. Although it did take a while for the finished product- it was worth the wait. Added a nice glass of French Bordeaux and a baguette and we had a very satisfying meal. Looking forward to the leftovers😁 Thank you Audrey for another great recipe.
Merci, Michele! Yes, the reason for the “18 cups OR enough to cover the ham hock” is because everyone’s pot is different. No real way to give an accurate measurement on account of that. That being said, you did the right thing and sounds like you nailed the recipe! This is a very flavorful soup that can cure any cold weather blues. Paired with wine and a baguette, and you have just about a perfect meal. So glad you enjoyed it, Michele, thanks for sharing!
Hi Audrey, I want to make this dish but I’m wondering about the large turnip you call for. Here in Canada a rutabaga is called turnip and I’m not sure whether you mean a rutabaga or a purple-topped turnip, the white turnip…you know what I mean 🙂 Could you please clarify? The Garbure sounds delicious! Thank you
What you referred to as a purple-topped turnip is what I used. I hope you enjoy it, Kathleen!
Hi Audrey! My husband is allergic to onion – do you think spiking the celery with cloves would have the same effect of imbuing the clove flavour?
Thanks!
Hello, Amy! If you’re thinking of making this dish without the onion, I would suggest maybe wrapping the cloves in cheesecloth or some sort of spice bag. The reason we stud the onion, is so the cloves are easy to discard of. Biting into a clove isn’t a very nice sensation, as the taste is very overwhelming. Celery gets soft easily and thus, the cloves could slip out. Cloves are essential to this dish, so you don’t want to leave them out, but you want to have a way to find them all so they don’t end up in your mouth.
Hi Audrey, Thanks for the recipe. I cooked it today and it was delicious!
I used a slow cooker on high setting. Took 7 1/2 hours total cooking.
First I cooked the hock with seasonings for 3 hours, Then I added the beans and flavourings – leeks and garlic, for another 3 hours.
Meanwhile I pre cooked the vegetables in some of the “stock” , then added butter after cooking. I lightly seasoned them too.
I removed the hocks and onion, and added them back as per recipe.
Then I added the cooked veggies and let it all simmer for 1 and 1/2 hours .
I adjusted quantities of flavourings as I had more weight on my hock.
I used water enough to cover hocks.
Thank you so much, Nolleen! So glad you enjoyed it, and so glad you gave a solid template on how to recreate this dish in a slow cooker for other readers. Much appreciated!
I used my pressure cooker. I cooked the ham hock in 9 cups of water with the clove studded onion, bay leaves, thyme and celery for 55 minutes. I naturally released the pressure. While that cooked I sautéed the garlic, turnip, carrots and leek. I blanched regular cabbage because 2 stores did not have savoy. I then added the sautéed vegetables, cut up celery and cooked onion, cabbage and potatoes, cut up ham and potatoes. I cooked all of this for 20 minutes high pressure and it was done without keeping the burner on so long. One question I have is that the recipe calls for 8-10 cloves of garlic which probably should have been added with the initial ham , celery etc. The recipe later down has 2 cloves of garlic. I just sautéed about 10 cloves with the other vegetables. I thought it tasted good. I added a little extra pepper when I ate it.
Hi, Debra and thank you so much for providing an alternative way of cooking this recipe for other readers. It is much appreciated!
In regards to the 8-10 cloves of garlic, it is actually 8-10 cloves (the spice) and not the garlic. I understand this is confusing not only you, but other readers as well. I just am a bit unsure how to clarify it in the recipe. You’re definitely not alone in this, and I’m sure using 8 cloves of garlic was delicious regardless!
I will have to think on how to clarify the difference, but appreciate the feedback! Bon appetit!
Merci!
You’re very welcome, Judy!
May I suggest that you refer to cloves as ‘whole cloves’, as that is how the package reads when you buy them, and would differentiate from garlic? Thank you for the quick answer to my question about blanching the savoy cabbage. I am enjoying perusing your recipes, and will be making many of them in the future.
Thank you, Patricia. That’s actually a good idea for the cloves, I appreciate it!
Wow. Bursting with flavour. I made this in my InstantPot, a half recipe, with a little less than half the liquid, following the steps laid out in the recipe but adjusted for the pressure cooker. It is delicious, and when done with a pressure cooker incredibly easy. To me it seems like a close cousin to choucroute (with home made sauerkraut), which I adore.
I had this with a dense very fresh sourdough rye (100% rye), which is a lovely companion. My only regret is that I didn’t have some very good butter from Brittany.
This definitely goes in the family dinner rotation.
Thank you so much, Michele, and great advice for readers who like to use an InstantPot for their cooking/to help speed things up! I’m certain many will find this useful.
I appreciate the kind words, and you nailed it with a fresh sourdough rye to accompany it. The perfect combo!
[…] 7. Garbure […]
This sounds wonderful, but I cannot for the life of me, understand why you need to blanch the savoy cabbage, as it spends a lot of time cooking in the soup later? Please explain.
Great question, Patricia! This step is absolutely optional if you’re not in the mood for doing it. The reason is two-fold. First, it’s what I always saw done growing up… I’m a traditionalist 🙂 Second, it softens the “harsh” cabbage flavor and makes it more subtle when added to the soup later. If you love a nice, strong cabbage taste, skip the blanching. No problem at all. I find by blanching it, the flavors of the soup harmonize a little better, allowing the taste of everything to be more present.
Dear Audrey, I just found you and I am so happy to have done so! I just came back from a holiday in the Béarn region (oh wow what a beautiful place!) but I was indeed served this soup there! Question: unfortunately my husband does not eat pork (and yes, eating out there was a little tricky at times). Do you think I could substitute a lamb shank and some smoked turkey bacon into the stock to get a similar flavour? I would love to make Garbure at home for us. Please advise! Warmest, Vanessa
No doubt that eating out would have been tricky, us French absolutely adore pork and use it in so many dishes. That being said, I think your ideas for substitutes would absolutely work. Many grocers also sell hunks of smoked turkey meat (wings and legs) which would also be a great option.
I say go for it and truly hope you’ll enjoy it! Let me know how it turned out, and hope you make it back to France soon 🙂
Oh I didn’t think of smoked turkey on the bone! I live in the Netherlands so I will see if I can get it. Great idea! Thank you so much!
If you can find it, it’s really good! Best of luck 🙂
IT WAS PERFECT!! NOT TOO MUCH WATER AT ALL!! PEOPLE NEED TO PAY ATTENTION TO THE DIRECTIONS MORE CAREFULLY. THANK YOU, IT WAS WONDERFUL!! CAN’T WAIT TO TRY MORE OF YOUR RECIPES.
So glad you enjoyed it, Debbie! Such a wonderful soup come cold weather season, I could really use a bowl today, we woke up with some seriously cold temps here (for our area). Yum!
this is just the recipe I was hoping to find-I may use a 1/4 tsp of ground clove
Hope this recipe hits the spot, Edward! Clove can be very overpowering if it’s overdone, so I think you’re right on track with 1/4tsp of ground clove. You can always add a small pinch more if you taste it halfway through and think it could use more. Enjoy!
This didn’t turn out well for me. The vegetables got in all an hour of simmering, and it turned them into mush. The cabbage, having been blanched, was then subjected to long cooking, and cancelled the reason for the blanching, or at least in Chinese cooking, where blanched vegetables are stir-fried only very lightly to keep the bright color. The cabbage in this dish hadn’t a chance to retain any color. The spices, the cloves, thyme, and red pepper flakes, with the strong smoked flavor from the hocks, didn’t seem to go together.
I’m very sorry to hear that, Janet. I know not every dish is for every one, and that’s ok. But it still bums me out when someone takes the time to enjoy a recipe and they’re not a fan of the end product. But I fully understand that some flavor combinations just don’t agree with every palate.